| 25 (257 to 252) Uruguay 1(1) - 1(1) Costa Rica (116 to 121) 25: 18NOV2009 |
| 25 (124 to 116) Costa Rica 0(0) - 1(1) Uruguay (249 to 257) 25: 14NOV2009 |
| 38 (-227 to -232) United States 2(2) - 6(2) Costa Rica (119 to 124) 38: 14OCT2009 |
| 38 (102 to 119) Costa Rica 4(4) - 0(0) Trinidad Tobago (63 to 30) 75: 10OCT2009 |
| 25 (-36 to -18) Salvador 1(1) - 0(0) Costa Rica (120 to 102) 25: 09SEP2009 |
| 25 (135 to 120) Costa Rica 1(0) - 3(3) Mexico (58 to 73) 25: 05SEP2009 |
| 38 (229 to 244) Honduras 4.5(4) - 0(0) Costa Rica (150 to 135) 38: 12AUG2009 |
| 25 (154 to 150) Costa Rica 2(1) - 2(2) Mexico (42 to 46) 25: 23JUL2009 |
| 135 (30 to -17) Guadeloupe 'C' 1.5(1) - 5(5) Costa Rica (141 to 154) 38: 19JUL2009 |
| 25 (138 to 141) Costa Rica 3(2) - 2(2) Canada (-209 to -217) 64: 10JUL2009 |
| 70 (39 to 13) Jamaica 0(0) - 1(1) Costa Rica (129 to 138) 25: 07JUL2009 |
| 25 (147 to 129) Costa Rica 1(1) - 2(2) Salvador (-29 to -11) 25: 03JUL2009 |
| 50 (76 to 55) Trinidad Tobago 2(2) - 3(3) Costa Rica (137 to 147) 25: 06JUN2009 |
| 38 (132 to 137) Costa Rica 7(3) - 1(1) United States (-183 to -188) 38: 03JUN2009 |
| 25 (-23 to -30) Venezuela 1(1) - 1.5(1) Costa Rica (125 to 132) 25: 12MAY2009 |
| 25 (118 to 125) Costa Rica 1(1) - 0(0) Salvador (-50 to -57) 25: 01APR2009 |
| 25 (12 to 29) Mexico 2(2) - 1(0) Costa Rica (135 to 118) 25: 28MAR2009 |
| 0 (135 to 135) Costa Rica 2(2) - 0.5(0) Honduras (195 to 195) 0: 11FEB2009 |
| 54 (60 to 94) Panama 1(1) - 0(0) Costa Rica (151 to 135) 25: 01FEB2009 |
| 25 (146 to 151) Costa Rica 1(1) - 0(0) Salvador (-74 to -79) 25: 30JAN2009 |
| 90 (-10 to -37) Guatemala 1(1) - 3(3) Costa Rica (139 to 146) 25: 25JAN2009 |
| 38 (126 to 139) Costa Rica 3(3) - 0(0) Panama (25 to -4) 81: 23JAN2009 |