| 70 (348 to 375) Costa Rica 2(1) - 1(1) Mexico (262 to 235) 70: 26OCT1957 |
| 70 (210 to 262) Mexico 2(2) - 1(0) Costa Rica (400 to 348) 70: 19OCT1957 |
| 100 (97 to 81) Netherlands Antilles 1.5(1) - 2(2) Costa Rica (389 to 400) 70: 03AUG1957 |
| 105 (371 to 389) Costa Rica 4(4) - 0.5(0) Netherlands Antilles (97 to 71) 150: 02MAR1957 |
| 70 (368 to 371) Costa Rica 3.5(3) - 1(1) Guatemala (-194 to -198) 100: 16FEB1957 |
| 150 (-188 to -194) Guatemala 2(2) - 6.5(6) Costa Rica (364 to 368) 105: 09FEB1957 |